Halloween is for Lovers

He brought her nothing. Four hundred years old, immortal, deathless, and not so much as a flower — and she is a witch, so she noticed, and she said so, and it escalated the way these things do. What you are looking at is the reconciliation. This is simply what they have: he gives her everything he took that evening, she gives him back the batch that went wrong, and both of them mean it, and neither one has ever said the word. Ask and they will tell you they are only friends who happen to be standing very close. Every couple has a thing. This is theirs.